Chardonnay Edge
- Pearl 2 Star Prestige · 2025
Saline, precise Chardonnay is the constant at A. Margaine; the return visit is less about discovering a new register than about seeing how firmly Villers-Marmery holds its anomaly inside the Montagne de Reims. The village sits as a Chardonnay island in a Pinot Noir zone, and that fact matters more here than any generic shorthand about grower Champagne. The house’s work is framed by near Blanc de Blancs logic from a site where Pinot Noir would normally set the regional grammar.
Villers-Marmery Chardonnay in a Pinot Noir mountain
The useful way to read the winery is through cépage and place. In the Montagne de Reims, Chardonnay usually plays a different role than it does on the Côte des Blancs: less as a broad regional identity, more as a local exception that can sharpen a blend when the site allows it. At the winery, that exception becomes the axis of the portfolio, giving the wines a luminous, saline, and exact profile rather than a Pinot-led Montagne shape.
NV Champagne Cuvée Le Brut makes the point directly: 88% Chardonnay, the balance Pinot Noir, with 55% from the 2019 vintage. That composition puts the cuvée close to Blanc de Blancs territory without erasing the Montagne context. For buyers or drinkers tracking value, the interest is not luxury positioning; it is the amount of Chardonnay character delivered from a village whose technical identity runs against its surrounding region.
Perpetual reserve as the deeper house marker
Le Caractère moves the discussion from village anomaly to reserve architecture. The cuvée is drawn from the domaine’s perpetual reserve, incorporating vintages from 2002 through 2018, which gives the wine’s frame a multi-vintage depth rather than a single-harvest signature. In Champagne terms, that is the more serious marker: not just freshness from Chardonnay, but continuity built through reserve material across sixteen listed years.
Questions
Frequently asked
What is offered at A. Margaine?
Margaine, the NV Champagne Cuvee Le Brut is 88% Chardonnay and the remainder Pinot Noir, with 55% from the 2019 vintage.
The field
How it compares
| Place | Notes | Awards |
|---|---|---|
| A. Margaine | Villers-Marmery, $$$ | · |
| Ata Rangi | Martinborough | World's 50 Best |
| Château Montrose | Saint-Estèphe | · |
| Chateau Mouton Rothschild | Pauillac | World's 50 Best |
| Creation Wines | Hermanus | World's 50 Best |
| Domaine Faiveley | Nuits-Saint-Georges | World's 50 Best |
| Domaine Jacques-Frédéric Mugnier | Premeaux-Prissey | · |