Colonie

Where Brooklyn Heights meets farm-to-table innovation, Colonie New York City transforms seasonal ingredients into neighborhood magic through Chef Andrew Whitcomb's sustainable culinary vision. This intimate dining destination honors New Amsterdam's Dutch heritage while championing the borough's evolving food culture. Colonie emerged as Brooklyn's answer to community-driven dining, with Chef Andrew Whitcomb rising from line cook to culinary leader. The Maine-born, CIA-trained chef has earned recognition as a Rising Star Chef for sustainability, building intimate relationships with regional growers and cultivating heirloom herbs in his own garden. His commitment to hyper-local sourcing reflects the restaurant's deeper philosophy: creating authentic connections between diners, ingredients, and community. Whitcomb's seasonal menu showcases New American dishes with historical reverence, featuring preparations like seared tilefish with herb-walnut pesto, pork chops with turnips, and fried rice with asparagus, ramps, and local mushrooms. The ricotta crostini has achieved cult status among regulars, while daily specials reflect the chef's market discoveries. This approach emphasizes comfort and refinement without pretension, with prix fixe options complementing à la carte selections. Architect Alex Meyers crafted Colonie's striking interior using exclusively recycled and reclaimed materials, creating an industrial-rustic atmosphere that feels both historic and contemporary. Repurposed church pews serve as banquettes, while reclaimed wood floors and ceilings frame communal tables anchored by adjustable steel beams. The antiqued glass bar mirror, salvaged from a historic Manhattan building, reflects Edison bulb warmth throughout the space. A vertical living garden adds botanical drama above the green bar, while the open kitchen's white subway tiles invite interaction between diners and culinary team. The beverage program mirrors the kitchen's sustainable philosophy, featuring natural wines, regional craft beers, and artisanal cocktails crafted with local ingredients. The sommelier's selections emphasize small producers and organic viticulture, with classic European touches like ruby port for cheese pairings. Service remains refreshingly unpretentious, encouraging conversation between guests and kitchen staff, particularly at the coveted bar seats overlooking the open kitchen. Colonie represents Brooklyn Heights dining at its most authentic, where reservations book quickly among locals and discerning visitors seeking genuine farm-to-table excellence. The restaurant's commitment to sustainability and community creates a dining room rooted in place, season, and craft.

How it compares

• Colonie

  Awards

  2 recognitions

  Cuisine

  Dining

  Notes

  Brooklyn Heights

• Ferdinando’s Focacceria

  Awards

  2 recognitions

  Cuisine

  Dining

  Notes

  Carroll Gardens-Cobble Hill-Gowanus-Red Hook

• Dimes

  Awards

  2 recognitions

  Cuisine

  Neighborhood American Cafe

  Notes

  Chinatown-Two Bridges, $$

• Sarabeth’s

  Awards

  2 recognitions

  Cuisine

  Brunch

  Notes

  Greenwich Village

• Silver Apricot

  Awards

  2 recognitions

  Cuisine

  Dining

  Notes

  West Village

• Achilles Heel

  Awards

  2 recognitions

  Cuisine

  Dining

  Notes

  Greenpoint